Retirement Insecurity Among Illinois Workers is on the Rise

Springfield, IL – The Illinois House of Representatives State Government Administration Committee will hold a hearing on the need for employment- based retirement savings in Illinois today. More than half of private sector Illinois workers do not have access to an employment-based retirement plan, a forthcoming report by the Illinois Asset Building Group and Woodstock Institute found. That means about 2.5 million workers are heavily depending on Social Security to sustain them in retirement, jeopardizing their financial security and the health of Illinois’ economy.

Low-income workers, particularly those in the service industry and those that are part-time, tend to be employed by businesses that do not currently offer access to retirement savings plans. Without access to employment-based retirement savings plans, Illinois residents will lack sufficient assets to support themselves in retirement. Currently, Social Security accounts for about 40% of retirement income (down from 52% in 1981), leaving many with insufficient finances in their retirement.

“Lack of access to retirement savings is a contributing factor to Illinois’ growing asset poverty rate—one that, if not addressed, will increasingly erode the financial security of our families,” says Karen Harris, Director of the Asset Opportunity Unit at the Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law and an IABG partner.

“Older Americans are a growing percentage of our population and are not adequately prepared for the financial needs of their retirement,” says Spencer Cowan, Vice President of Woodstock Institute. “Illinois needs a public policy solution that allows workers to save for their future, no matter where they work.”

Automatic Individual Retirement Accounts are innovative solutions that can bridge the retirement savings gap, especially for low- to moderate-income workers.  Automatic IRA legislation (HB 4497 / SB 3278) was introduced this year in the Illinois General Assembly.

Under HB4497 / SB3278, small employers with more than 10 and less than 100 employees, who have been in business for at least 2 years and who have not, during such 2 year period, offered a retirement plan would be required to automatically enroll their employees in a payroll deduction direct deposit Automatic IRA account. Employees could opt-out of this plan at any time.

To increase efficiency and economies of scale, these Auto IRA accounts would be pooled and administered by the Illinois Treasurer’s Office. Start up costs for the Treasurer’s Office could be minimized to the greatest extent possible by using the State’s existing 529 college savings structure as a platform for the Automatic IRA accounts.  Additionally, as the accounts grow, the start-up costs and administrative costs would be repaid from the proceeds generated from the accounts and the program would become self-sustaining.

According to Nancy Nelson, Manager of Advocacy and Outreach for AARP Illinois, the Automatic IRA program is “a low-cost and common sense Springfield, IL—The Illinois House of Representatives State Government Administration Committee will hold a hearing on the need for employment-based retirement savings in Illinois today. More than half of private sector Illinois workers do not have access to an employment-based retirement plan, a forthcoming report by the Illinois Asset Building Group and Woodstock Institute found. That means about 2.5 million workers are heavily depending on Social Security to sustain them in retirement, jeopardizing their financial security and the health of Illinois’ economy.

Low-income workers, particularly those in the service industry and those that are part-time, tend to be employed by businesses that do not currently offer access to retirement savings plans. Without access to employment-based retirement savings plans, Illinois residents will lack sufficient assets to support themselves in retirement. Currently, Social Security accounts for about 40% of retirement income (down from 52% in 1981), leaving many with insufficient finances in their retirement.

“Lack of access to retirement savings is a contributing factor to Illinois’ growing asset poverty rate—one that, if not addressed, will increasingly erode the financial security of our families,” says Karen Harris, Director of the Asset Opportunity Unit at the Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law and an IABG partner.

“Older Americans are a growing percentage of our population and are not adequately prepared for the financial needs of their retirement,” says Spencer Cowan, Vice President of Woodstock Institute. “Illinois needs a public policy solution that allows workers to save for their future, no matter where they work.”

Automatic Individual Retirement Accounts are an innovative solution that can bridge the retirement savings gap, especially for low- to moderate-income workers.  Automatic IRA legislation (H.B. 4497 / SB 3278) was introduced this year in the Illinois General Assembly.

Under H.B. 4497/SB3278, small employers with more than 10 and less than 100 employees, who have been in business for at least 2 years and who have not, during such 2 year period, offered a retirement plan would be required to automatically enroll their employees in a payroll deduction direct deposit Automatic IRA account. Employees could opt-out of this plan at any time.

To increase efficiency and economies of scale, these Auto IRA accounts would be pooled and administered by the Illinois Treasurer’s Office. Start up costs for the Treasurer’s Office could be minimized to the greatest extent possible by using the State’s existing 529 college savings structure as a platform for the Automatic IRA accounts.  Additionally, as the accounts grow, the start-up costs and administrative costs would be repaid from the proceeds generated from the accounts and the program would become self-sustaining.

According to Nancy Nelson, Manager of Advocacy and Outreach for AARP Illinois, the Automatic IRA program is “a low-cost and common sense solution to the problem that too many Americans are saving too little for retirement or aren’t saving at all. This is largely due to the fact that too few employers provide access, either by choice or by need, to an employment-based retirement savings vehicle.”

Almost all larger firms administer a retirement plan for their workers. By establishing a retirement account that small businesses can successfully administer, the Automatic IRA proposal provides small employers with a competitive benefit at a minimal cost.

Auto IRAs are a tool that Illinois workers can use to help them save for their own retirement. When given an opportunity to save, low-income families do save and save at a higher percentage of their income than do more wealthy families. Auto IRAs are a chance to give Illinois workers the opportunity to build financially secure futures.

More information about the Automatic IRAs, including written testimony from the hearing and fact sheets, can be found at http://www.fifal.local/autoira/policyrecommendations.

###

The Illinois Asset Building Group (IABG), a project of Heartland Alliance for Human Needs & Human Rights and the Shriver Center, is a statewide coalition committed to building financial security for all households. We believe that everyone deserves the opportunity to save for their future and the future of their children. Through partnerships with leaders and organizations across the state, IABG advocates for the creation of tools that help people build safe, stable futures.

IABG and Woodstock Institute will be releasing a report later this spring about the retirement savings landscape in Illinois.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

Secure Choice Pilot Program Launches

We are facing a national retirement savings crisis. Increasingly, older adults do not have enough...

Read more

New Report Sheds Light on Barriers to Retirement Savings

A new report released today by our friends at Heartland Alliance’s Social IMPACT Research...

Read more

Congress Moves to Expand the Racial Wealth Gap

At a time when wealth inequity is at extremes, it’s been incredibly disappointing to see...

Read more

Are you Money Smart?

55Money Smart Week, in its 10th year, appropriately falls during April’s National Financial Literacy Month. The public awareness campaign stresses the importance of financial literacy and offers free educational seminars from April 21-28. IABG partners across the state are hosting workshop and seminars to help households build their financial stability.

Throughout Chicago, Heartland Alliance’s Asset Building Program is offering financial education workshops that are open to the public.  We’ll be hosting the following events:

April 24th: Own Your Values & Financial Future
How do you decide how to spend your money?  This workshop will focus on discovering how your priorities and values impact your spending and savings habits.
When: Tuesday, April 24th, 3:00 to 5:00 pm
Where: Heartland Alliance – 400 W. 76th St. Suite 110 in Chicago
RSVP to: Karen – 773.336.6078

April 24th: Make Credit Work for You (in Spanish)
Confused by credit? We’ll discuss what credit is, when to use it, and how to access and understand your credit report and score.
When: Tuesday, April 24th, 6:00 to 8:00 pm
Where: Park Federal Bank/Neighborhood Housing Services – 1823 W. 47th Street in Chicago
RSVP to: Gloria – 773.358.3854

April 25th: Speed Banking
What bank is right for you?  Learn how to assess banks and different banking products based on your needs.  Get answers to your banking questions.  Bilingual representatives from local banks and credit unions will be present to give individualized attention.
When: Wednesday April 25th, 5:30 to 7:30 pm
Where: Chicago Math & Science Academy – 7212 N. Clark in Chicago
RSVP to: Carmen – 773.336.6051

April 25th: How to Buy a Good Used Car
Looking for a used car?  Learn what to look for and how to get a good deal.  Talk with representatives from North Side Federal Credit Union about financing options.
When: Wednesday April 25th, 6:00 to 8:00 pm
Where: Heartland Alliance – 1207 W. Leland in Chicago
RSVP to: Kimberly – 773.336.6033

April 25th: Make Credit Work for You
Confused by credit? We’ll discuss what credit is, when to use it, and how to access and understand your credit report and score.
When: Wednesday, April 25th, 6:00 to 8:00 pm
Where: Parkside of Old Town – Community Room – 544 W. Oak St., 3rd Floor, in Chicago
RSVP to: Shuron – 312.399.4839

April 25th: Achieve Your Goals – Assets Made Possible
Planning to make a big purchase?  Learn the basics of preparing for large ticket items, such as purchasing a home.  We’ll talk about credit requirements, down payments, mortgages, predatory lending and much more!
When: Wednesday, April 25th, 6:00 to 8:00 pm
Where: Northern Trust Bank – 7801 S. State Street in Chicago
RSVP to: Larry – 773.358.3850

In addition to these offerings, Heartland Alliance & Heartland Human Care Services is partnering with several groups to offer private financial education workshops to their employees and other community stakeholders during Money Smart Week, including PNC Bank, Urban Partnership Bank, S&C Electric, the Illinois Education Foundation, and the local Army Battalion.  For more information about financial education and HHCS asset building programs, please email me, Carmen Jimenez, or call 773.336.6051.

We hope you’ll join us for Money Smart Week!

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

IABG Launches Biannual Coalition Connection Meetings

This blog post is written by Katherine Liu, Communications Intern with Heartland Alliance.  ...

Read more

IABG Partner Spotlight: New CSA Program at Center for Changing Lives

This is a guest blog post by Kayla Villalobos with IABG partner, Center for Changing Lives. Center...

Read more

Peoria Re-Entry Program Uses Consumer Bureau Toolkit to Prepare Individuals for Successful Return to Community

Image: Andy Kravetz This blog post was jointly written by Janice Parker with Navicore Solutions and...

Read more

Small Dollar Lending Guidelines from the CFPB

Katy Welter
Chicago Appleseed Fund for Justice

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)  released “Examination Procedures: Short-term, Small Dollar Lending,” (pdf) which are guidelines for examining small dollar loan products. The guidelines are written for financial institution examiners, but offer insight into the CFPB’s expectations for five key areas affecting small dollar lending:

  1. Marketing
  2. Application and Origination of Loans
  3. Payment and Processing and Sustained Use
  4. Collection, Accounts in Default, and Consumer Reporting
  5. Third-Party Relationships

Publication of the guidelines accompanied a January 19, 2012 CFPB press release announcing the agency’s first-ever field hearing on the payday lending market. In that release, newly appointed CFPB Director Richard Cordray stated that the CFPB “will be giving payday lenders much more attention.”

The release states that the CFPB is authorized to regulate small dollar loans made by all institutions, including payday lenders. It says:

“The CFPB will be implementing its payday lending supervision program based on its assessment of risks to consumers, including consideration of factors such as the volume of business and the extent of state oversight. The CFPB also will be coordinating with federal and state partners to maximize supervisory capability and minimize regulatory burden. If a violation of a federal consumer financial law has occurred, the CFPB will determine whether supervisory or enforcement actions are appropriate.”

In Illinois, a state law passed in 2011 offers consumers certain protections against payday lenders. The law prohibits unlimited rollovers and requires loans are based on a borrower’s ability to pay. Even with these reforms, payday loans still are expensive. The APR on a payday loan can run as high as 400%.

Illinois consumers who can’t pay off a payday loan when it’s due are entitled to enter into an interest-free repayment plan after more than 35 days. It is against the law for lenders to issue a new payday loan if it would indebt a borrower for more than 45 days in a row.

The CFPB guidelines offer a comprehensive overview of all laws and regulations affecting small dollar lending. They also hint at practices within each topic the CFPB deems particularly important to examiners:

  • Marketing: Fair marketing methods, especially with respect to the use and compensation of lead generators.
  • Application and Origination of Loans: Electronic Fund Transfer (EFT) and Automated Clearing House (ACH) authorizations, fair and straightforward disclosure of loan terms, repayment terms, and consumers’ rights to dispute.
  • Payment Processing and Sustained Use: Traditional compliance with Regulations B and Z, with an eye toward lenders’ use of “rollovers” and other potentially unfair or deceptive practices that may encourage debt dependence. Regulation B prohibits lenders from discriminating against credit applicants, establishes guidelines for gathering and evaluating credit information, and requires written notification when credit is denied. Regulation Z requires uniform methods for disclosing credit terms and costs.
  • Collections, Accounts in Default, and Consumer Reporting: Compliance with existing Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, and use of 
”deceptive means” to collect debts.
  • Third-Party Relationships: Adherence to Gramm-Leach-Bliley privacy safeguards in place with both affiliate and third-party vendor agreements.

The Illinois Asset Building Group is currently developing a small dollar loan toolkit. The toolkit will offer guidelines as well as a profitability model, enabling mainstream financial institutions to add small dollar loans to their portfolios.

Learn more about the Chicago Appleseed Fund for Justice, an IABG Partner.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

Illinois Laws Let Debt Collectors Push Families into Poverty as Pandemic Protections Expire

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: NOVEMBER 10, 2021 Financial Inclusion for All Illinois: Amy Eisenstein,...

Read more

Historic legislation to prevent predatory loans passes Illinois General Assembly

For Immediate Release: January 13, 2021 Contact: Abe Scarr, Illinois PIRG, abe@illinoispirg.org,...

Read more

2019 Legislative Roundup: Illinois Takes Steps to Help Families Build Financial Security

IABG advocates for policies that close the racial wealth divide, expand savings opportunities, and...

Read more

National Financial Literacy Month: Improving Access & Quality

Last year, President Obama proclaimed April as National Financial Literacy Month, calling it a time to “recommit to improving financial literacy and ensuring all Americans have access to trustworthy financial services and products.”financialliteracymonth

Our advocacy focuses on asset building among low-income populations and financial education is an important component. While our efforts are year-round, we believe highlighting financial literacy in April only helps spread the message to more people.

Financial education is critical to developing financial literacy, which results in smarter consumers who optimize their household budgets to create greater opportunity to pay off debt, save and invest. Financial education helps consumers avoid financially destructive transactions and fraud while teaching them how to exercise their rights as consumers.

Research shows that youth who receive financial education gain skills and tools to secure lifelong financial health.

  • 86% of youth participating in financial education curriculum demonstrated an increase in financial knowledge or behavior when dealing with money.
  • Three months after participating in a financial education course:
    • 58% improved their spending habits
    • 56% improved their savings habits
    • 39% identified starting a savings account as the program’s most important impact
  • Five years after high school, students with mandated financial education in high school had self-reported savings rates 1.5% higher than those without mandated education.
  • Youth involvement in financial education encourages other family members to save and/ or pursue post-secondary education.

These statistics call for increased financial education in Illinois schools. Currently, financial education is a minor part of the public school curriculum, which shortchanges students now and for the future.

Developing financial literacy is needed among consumers of all ages and particularly among low-income consumers who face multiple challenges.

Several resources are available this month to promote financial literacy. Money Smart Week, in its 10th year, appropriately falls during April. The public awareness campaign stresses the importance of financial literacy and offers free educational seminars from April 21-28. You can search for events in Illinois on the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago website.

The nonprofit group Money Management International created a website for National Financial Literacy Month to educate and assist consumers in achieving financial wellness. Check out the site’s Thirty Steps to Financial Wellness and join the 2012 Financial Literacy Challenge for a chance to win $500.

As Money Management International points out, too many individuals and families are not sufficiently educated about their personal finances. As a country, we have more than $2 trillion in consumer debt and 30% of consumers report having no extra cash, which makes it impossible to escape of living paycheck to paycheck.

So, this month, let’s move closer to financial stability by recommitting to increasing access to effective financial education for all.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

IABG Launches Biannual Coalition Connection Meetings

This blog post is written by Katherine Liu, Communications Intern with Heartland Alliance.  ...

Read more

IABG Partner Spotlight: New CSA Program at Center for Changing Lives

This is a guest blog post by Kayla Villalobos with IABG partner, Center for Changing Lives. Center...

Read more

Peoria Re-Entry Program Uses Consumer Bureau Toolkit to Prepare Individuals for Successful Return to Community

Image: Andy Kravetz This blog post was jointly written by Janice Parker with Navicore Solutions and...

Read more