50 Years After the March on Washington the Racial Wealth Gap Widens

The March on Washington was a seminal moment in American history. As we reflect on where we are 50 years later, after policy advances like the Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act, and Community Reinvestment Act, we still see vast wealth inequalities between white households and households of color.

Financial security can be boiled down into two parts: income, which allows households to pay the bills and feed a family, and wealth, which is the amount of money a household has in checking, savings, and retirement accounts, or invested in their home, business, or other asset. With sufficient wealth a family can weather job loss or unexpected costs without having to take out costly loans or fall into serious financial hardship. Enough wealth allows parents to send children to college without burdening them with lifelong student debt. Enough savings allows retirees to enjoy their golden years in dignity. Wealth is access to the American dream. And perhaps most importantly, wealth, and the financial security associated with it, can be generational as financially secure parents can put their children through college, help them with a first home’s down payment, or, in cases of an emergency or job loss, provide a monetary bridge over financially difficult times.

Today’s racial wealth gap between White households and Latino or African-American households is massive. In 2009, Pew Research found that White households have 20 times the median net wealth of African-American households and 17 times the median net wealth of Hispanic households.

RWG_median wealth graph

Unfortunately, in the 50 years since the March on Washington the racial wealth gap has grown  by a staggering amount. A recent study out of Brandeis University following households from 1984 to 2009, found that the racial wealth gap grew 300% in 25 years. Perhaps the most disturbing finding was that for every $1 increase in average household income over the 25 year study, White households increased their wealth by $5.19, whereas African-American household only increased their wealth by $0.69. This highlights, in stark terms, the unequal access to critical wealth building tools for households and communities of color.

Illinois Policies to Close the Racial Wealth Gap

Illinois Automatic IRA Program: More and more seniors are retiring into poverty. Over 53% or 2.5 million Illinois workers lack access to an employer-based retirement account, the most effective and utilized way to save for retirement. Low-wage workers have even less access to employer-based retirement accounts, and providing that access will help close the gap. An Auto IRA program will give Illinois workers the tools they need to retire with dignity.

Universal Children’s Savings Accounts in Illinois: Kids with a Children’s Savings Account (CSA) in their name are 6 times more likely to go to college. The aspirational impact of CSA’s makes it potentially one of the most powerful ways to reduce the gap. A Universal CSA program in Illinois would open up a CSA for every child born in the state, seed it with a financial contribution, and provide a match component for low-income families. This would create greater opportunity for low-income communities and communities of color to save for their children’s education.

IABG has held several Racial Wealth Gap Roundtables in Illinois communities, where community leaders shared how the gap manifests in their community and learned about the policies that contributed to the Racial Wealth Gap and the policies, like those described above, that can close it. Our next roundtable will be on Chicago’s West Side. If you are interested in participating in that event or would like for us to hold one in your community please contact Lucy Mullany.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

Historic legislation to prevent predatory loans passes Illinois General Assembly

For Immediate Release: January 13, 2021 Contact: Abe Scarr, Illinois PIRG, abe@illinoispirg.org,...

Read more

2019 Legislative Roundup: Illinois Takes Steps to Help Families Build Financial Security

IABG advocates for policies that close the racial wealth divide, expand savings opportunities, and...

Read more

Illinois Senate Passes Children’s Savings Account Legislation

ILLINOIS CSA PROGRAM WOULD BE THE LARGEST IN THE COUNTRY & MAKE IT 3 TIMES MORE LIKELY...

Read more

New Statistics on the American Retirement Savings Crisis

Karen Harris

Are you confident about your retirement? According to the latest retirement confidence survey, 28% of Americans are not at all confident, and 21% are not too confident that they will have enough money saved for a comfortable retirement. These views are essentially unchanged from the record low levels of retirement confidence seen in the 2011 survey.  The sad part is that for most American’s these retirement fears are well-grounded.

Nearly half, 48%, of all elderly Americans are “economically vulnerable,” meaning that they have income that is less than two times the supplemental poverty threshold.  People who are aged 80 and older are particularly prone to economic vulnerability (58.1% are economically vulnerable versus 44.4% for people aged 65 to 79), as are women (52.6% versus 41.9%) and minorities (63.5% African Americans and 70.1% Hispanics versus 43.8% whites).

These figures, which derive from a new report by the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), use the Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM) in order to measure the financial security or insecurity of elderly Americans.

The SPM, which was released in 2011, is an attempt to update the current federal poverty measure that, it is generally agreed, is outdated and therefore underestimates the level of poverty in the U.S.  The SPM takes into account household expenses such as taxes, housing, utilities, health care costs, child support payments, and work-related expenses (i.e., travel and child care). This is offset by including the value of government income supplements, such as subsidized school lunch programs, energy assistance programs, housing subsidies, and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (previously food stamps), that are not accounted for in the official poverty measure. The result is that the new calculation more accurately reflects how low-income Americans are actually getting by.  Thus, when examining poverty using the official measure, non-elderly people (ages 19-64) have a higher rate of poverty compared to seniors (13.4% versus 8.9%), however, when using the supplemental poverty measure, seniors have a higher rate of poverty than non-elderly adults (15.5% versus 15.1%).

These data on the financial vulnerability of elderly Americans was released at the same time that the National Institute on Retirement Security released a new report on the current state of retirement savings in America.  The study confirms the need for greater retirement savings access, particularly, the need for an Automatic IRA program. According to the report, there is awidespread lack retirement savings in the U.S.  Specifically, 38 million working-age households (45%) do not own any retirement account assets.  While experts estimate that, in order to replace 85% of pre-retirement income, families must save 8 to 11 times their annual income, 80% of all working people ages 25-64 have less than 1 times their annual income in retirement savings. For all households, those who do and do not have retirement accounts, the median retirement account balance is $3,000, and just $12,000 for those nearing retirement.  Americans need to save an additional estimated $6.8 to $14 trillion in order to be financially secure in retirement.

One of the reasons for this dramatic shortfall is that many employees lack access to employer based retirement savings accounts, which is the primary way that people begin saving for retirement.  In 2011, 52% of employees had access to employer sponsored retirement savings, a 20% drop in just a decade.

Moreover, retirement accounts are concentrated among the wealthy.  Eighty-nine percent of households in the top income quartile, and 72% of households in the second highest income quartile have retirement accounts, while just 51.1% of households in the second lowest quartile and a mere 26% of households in the lowest income quartile have retirement savings accounts.  The median income of families with retirement accounts is $76,238, whereas the median income for families without retirement accounts is $30,495.

These studies further demonstrate that there is a great need for broader access to retirement savings for workers.  One policy proposal that is gaining traction is the Automatic IRA. In 2012, the California state legislature passed the California Choice Retirement Savings Trust Act, which lays the initial groundwork for creating a statewide retirement plan for private sector workers who do not have access to an employer-sponsored savings plan.  In 2013, the Illinois Asset Building Group (IABG) in partnership with our lead partners at Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law, and others are promoting SB 2400, which would create an automatic IRA program in Illinois.

Under the bill all employers with more than 10 employees, that have been in business at least two years, and have not offered a qualifying retirement plan for the past two years would be required to automatically enroll their employees in an automatic payroll deduction. The employer would, on behalf of the employee, deposit this deduction into an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) that is held by the state. Employees would have the ability to select their contribution rates and investment option, or opt-out of the deduction entirely. If an employee did not make any selection then she would be automatically enrolled in a default target-date lifecycle investment option with a 3% income contribution rate.

All investments would be overseen by the Automatic IRA Program Board established by the bill. This board would consist of seven members: The State Treasurer (serving as chair), the State Comptroller, the Director of the Governor’s Office of Management and Budget, as well as two public representatives with retirement savings and or investment expertise, a representative of employers, and a representative of enrollees, each of whom would be appointed by the Governor. The board would contract with third-party investment firms to invest and administer the fund. All interest and income earned from the investment fund would remain in the fund. Administrative fees charged on the interest on the fund would pay for initial startup costs and ongoing administration. The program would add minimal cost to employers, and employees would have the option to opt-out.

We are building a strong campaign to move the legislation forward next year. Join the Campaign today, and help us build financially secure retirements for all workers in Illinois.

 

*This blog was originally posted here from Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

Historic legislation to prevent predatory loans passes Illinois General Assembly

For Immediate Release: January 13, 2021 Contact: Abe Scarr, Illinois PIRG, abe@illinoispirg.org,...

Read more

2019 Legislative Roundup: Illinois Takes Steps to Help Families Build Financial Security

IABG advocates for policies that close the racial wealth divide, expand savings opportunities, and...

Read more

Illinois Senate Passes Children’s Savings Account Legislation

ILLINOIS CSA PROGRAM WOULD BE THE LARGEST IN THE COUNTRY & MAKE IT 3 TIMES MORE LIKELY...

Read more

Your Voice Is Needed to End Poverty in Illinois

speaker picIn Illinois today, 39 out of our 102 counties are currently on a state wide Poverty Warning or Poverty Watch alert. With poverty touching so many of us across the state the Illinois Commission on the Elimination of Poverty and Heartland Alliance are looking to hear from YOU! If poverty has touched your life in some way your story can help shape key anti-poverty legislation.

The Illinois Commission on the Elimination of Poverty is holding two upcoming public hearings to listen to the public share both their personal stories related to poverty and their recommendations on policies the state should advance to cut extreme poverty. These hearings are specifically geared to make sure that the Commission’s work and recommendations are informed by the experiences of individuals living in poverty. Policy makers are listening – your voice can make all the difference.

The first hearing is being held in Rockford Illinois on Wednesday August 21st.  If you live near Rockford and have been personally affected by poverty you are encouraged to come out, share your story, and make a difference!

Rockford, IL – The Illinois Commission on the Elimination of Poverty

  • When: Wednesday August 21st 2013
  • Time: 6:00pm – 8:00pm
  • Where: Zeke Giorgi Center – Auditorium, 200 S. Wyman  Rockford, Illinois 61101
  • NOTE: Food will be served, transportation reimbursement for those who qualify – Questions contact Kim Drew kdrew@heartlandalliance.org / (312) 870-4948

The second hearing is being held in Chicago Illinois on Tuesday September 3rd.  Again, if you or someone you know lives in the Chicagoland area and has been impacted by poverty, you are encouraged to come out, share your story, and make a difference!

Chicago, IL – The Illinois Commission on the Elimination of Poverty

  • When:  Tuesday, September 3rd 2013
  • Time: 7:00pm – 9:00pm
  • Where: Illinois Institute of Technology – McCormick Tribune Campus Center – Ballroom,  3301 S. State Street  Chicago, Illinois 60616
  • NOTE: Refreshments will be served. Childcare will be provided upon request. Transportation reimbursement is available for qualifying individuals. Free parking available after 7pm in A4 Visitor lot (32nd and State) and D5 Visitor Lot (34th and State). Accessible via State St Bus, 35th St bus, Metra (35th Lou Jones Stop), Green Line – 35th / IIT, and Red Line- Sox 35th. Questions contact Kim Drew kdrew@heartlandalliance.org / (312) 870-4948

Please spread the word about these upcoming events and join us as we shape a better Illinois. If you are unable to attend but would still like to make an impact you can submit your comments and questions to Kim Drew (kdrew@heartlandalliance.org / (312) 870-4948) or post directly to the Illinois Commission on the Elimination of Poverty website (http://www2.illinois.gov/poverty/Pages/default.aspx). Your voice, your opinion, and your story can make a positive change for millions of families living in poverty in this state.  Policy makers are listening – your voice can make all the difference.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

2019 Legislative Roundup: Illinois Takes Steps to Help Families Build Financial Security

IABG advocates for policies that close the racial wealth divide, expand savings opportunities, and...

Read more

Racial Disparities Exist Across All Measures of Financial Security in Illinois

By Sarah Martin, Policy & Advocacy Intern for Heartland Alliance Prosperity Now’s annual...

Read more

IABG Launches Biannual Coalition Connection Meetings

This blog post is written by Katherine Liu, Communications Intern with Heartland Alliance.  ...

Read more

The Affordable Care Act & the Unbanked: Part 2

This is the second blog in a two part blog series on the Unbanked and the Uninsured.

In our first blog of this series we discussed the unique challenges facing unbanked households when they try to pay for health insurance.

An estimated 36% of currently uninsured households in our state have no checking or savings accounts and are effectively “unbanked.” The problem is that the vast majority of insurance companies require individuals to pay their monthly premiums via automatic withdrawal from a checking account. This means if you don’t have a checking account, you can’t get insurance.

In an effort to address this challenge, the Department of Health and Human Services released proposed rules that would require insurers to accept a menu of payment options, including paper checks, cashier’s checks, money orders, and prepaid debit cards.

In response to these proposed rules, IABG submitted a letter in partnership with 78 other organizations engaged with CFED’s Assets & Opportunity Network. The letter includes recommendations on how the Department and other state and federal agencies can ensure that a pathway to safe banking opportunities is a part of ACA implementation. The recommendations include:

  • Deductions from Paychecks: Automatic withdrawals from payroll help facilitate on-time payment. Similar to retirement savings or social security deductions, payroll deductions for insurance purchased on the exchange will ensure regular on-time payments.
  • Ability to Pay in Advance: If open enrollment in states across the country were aligned with tax time, consumers could pay for their premiums via their tax return. The Department of the Treasury should explore mechanisms for streamlining payments through resources consumers receive at tax time. Many Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) sites work with the unbanked population and can facilitate community outreach for this payment option.
  • Use of Navigators: Navigators should be required to provide payment information to each consumer who is purchasing health insurance via the Marketplace. Navigators can be key ambassadors of this information. We recommend creating FAQs on payment options for this formerly uninsured population.
  • Website Development: Each state will have either its own website or they will be referring people to the federal website to access the Marketplace. Payment information should be provided on the website and should be sent to consumers via email or traditional mail upon purchasing their insurance. Given that immigrants make up a significant percentage of the unbanked community, this information should be accessible in a variety of languages.

Pathway to Safe Banking

While we support efforts to ensure that the unbanked have access to health insurance through the marketplaces, we also strongly believe that DHS should use this as an opportunity to provide pathways to safe affordable banking. Being banked will facilitate on time payments which will ensure continuity of coverage and access to health care. While the alternative payments proposed by the Department are important to improve access to health care, they are costly and not a long term solution.  IABG will continue to work with healthcare advocates to implement changes that will create a pathway to banking.

You Might Also Be Interested In...

Read our blog

2019 Legislative Roundup: Illinois Takes Steps to Help Families Build Financial Security

IABG advocates for policies that close the racial wealth divide, expand savings opportunities, and...

Read more

Part 2: Increasing Financial Inclusion for People with Disabilities

By Sarah Martin, Policy & Advocacy Intern for Heartland Alliance Nationwide, the poverty rate...

Read more

Part 1: Barriers to Financial Inclusion for People with Disabilities

By Sarah Martin, Policy & Advocacy Intern for Heartland Alliance In Illinois 1 in 5 households...

Read more